top of page
Minerals and Stones

Islam and Christianity: Why Christians Cannot Accept Islam’s Claims About Jesus

3 hours ago
5 min read
Two men discuss two open religious texts across a wooden table in a sunlit stone study.

 

What does Islam teach about Jesus, and why should a Christian care? The Qur’an honors Jesus as the Messiah and a messenger from God. The New Testament calls Him the eternal Son who became flesh, died for our sins, and rose from the dead. Both faiths speak of Jesus with reverence. They make incompatible claims about who He is and what He did.

 

A Christian should reject Islamic teaching where it contradicts the gospel. The reason is specific. If you deny that Jesus is the divine Son, or that He died and rose for us, you give up the very claims Paul places at the center of Christian faith. You owe your Muslim neighbor the same honesty and respect you would want him to show you.

 

Who is Jesus in Islam and Christianity?

 

The Qur’an calls Jesus the Messiah and a messenger of God. It presents His birth to Mary as miraculous. In the same passage calling Him God’s messenger, it tells readers not to say “Three” and rejects the idea of God having a son. Surah 112 also declares God’s oneness and says He does not beget. These passages give Jesus a significant place in Islam while drawing a clear line against divine sonship.

 

 

John opens his Gospel by saying the Word was with God and was God. John then says the Word became flesh and lived among us. Read those statements together. John distinguishes the Word from the One He was with and attributes deity to the Word. The Nicene Creed likewise confesses one God and describes the Son as eternally begotten, fully divine, and of one being with the Father. “Son” here refers to an eternal relationship within God, without any claim of physical procreation.

 

 

Notice what happens when Thomas meets the risen Jesus. Earlier, Thomas insists on seeing the wounds. When Jesus meets him, Thomas addresses Him as his Lord and his God. John follows the scene by telling readers he wrote so they would believe Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and have life in His name. The title “Messiah” must be understood in light of what each source says about Jesus.

 

 

Did Jesus die on the cross according to Islam?

 

Qur’an 4:157 says those who claimed to have killed Jesus neither killed nor crucified Him. It says the event appeared so to them. Verse 158 says God raised Him to Himself. Mainstream Muslim interpretation understands this as a denial that Jesus was crucified. The passage itself gives no name for a substitute. If someone supplies a name, ask which commentary or tradition gives it.

 

 

In 1 Corinthians 15, Paul reminds the church of the message it received. Christ died for our sins, was buried, was raised on the third day, and appeared to witnesses. Paul then takes up a dispute among the Corinthians over the resurrection of the dead. If Christ has not been raised, Paul says, their faith is futile and they are still in their sins. Paul answers by declaring Christ has risen.

 

 

The Christian claim includes a real death followed by resurrection. Saying God took Jesus to Himself means something different in a passage denying His killing and crucifixion. When you compare the two texts, ask what each says happened before God raised Jesus. That question keeps the discussion on the event each text describes.

 

Illustrated comparison of Islam and Christianity on Jesus’ identity and crucifixion, with biblical references and a practical guide to respectful conversation.

 

Why Christians trust Jesus for forgiveness

 

Romans 3 treats sin as a problem shared by all and presents God’s grace in Christ as the answer. Ephesians 2 describes salvation as God’s gift, received through faith, and says God made His people in Christ for good works. Read verses 8 through 10 together. Grace gives you a reason to obey and serve without treating your record as the basis of your standing with God.

 

 

Give a Muslim friend’s beliefs a fair hearing. The Qur’an urges sinners to hope in God’s mercy and turn to Him. The disagreement concerns the role of Jesus’ death and resurrection in forgiveness. For a Christian, faith rests on the work of the risen Christ. Adopting the Islamic account of Jesus would change whom you trust and why.

 

 

How to discuss the differences with a Muslim friend

 

Peter tells believers facing opposition to explain the reason for their hope with gentleness and respect. Put Peter’s instruction into practice at work, at your dinner table, or with a friend who sends you a debate clip. Ask one question at a time and give the other person room to answer.

 

 

Ask what the person means

 

Try asking, “What does the title Messiah mean to you when you use it for Jesus?” Listen to the answer. Repeat it in your own words and give your friend a chance to correct you. If you are speaking with your son or daughter, start by asking what they heard and what made it persuasive.

 

Read both passages in full

 

Set Qur’an 4:157–158 alongside 1 Corinthians 15:1–20. Write down what each text claims about Jesus’ death. Then switch to John 1:1–18 and Qur’an 4:171. Ask what each passage says about who Jesus is. If a question goes beyond what you have read, write it down and look it up before offering a confident answer.

 

Hands gather around two open books and a notebook to compare what the passages say about Jesus.

 

Explain what you believe in one sentence

 

Try saying, “I trust Jesus as the Son of God who died for our sins and rose again.” If someone asks why Jesus prayed to the Father, read a Gospel passage together and discuss how the Son relates to the Father. The article below works through the question in detail.

 

 

Does reading the Qur’an compromise Christian faith?

 

Reading a source to understand a neighbor’s beliefs is different from accepting its authority. If a conversation unsettles you, identify the exact claim you are wrestling with. Read its context, then take your question to a trusted pastor or a mature Christian friend. For a family discussion this week, read 1 Corinthians 15:1–20 together and ask why Paul connects forgiveness to the resurrection.

 

Related teaching

 

In this Zondervan video, Nabeel Qureshi addresses how Christians and Muslims speak about God. His answer offers a Christian apologetics perspective to consider alongside the passages above.

 

 

 

Recommended book

 

No God but One: Allah or Jesus? by Nabeel Qureshi

 

Qureshi examines where Islam and Christianity disagree and presents his assessment of the evidence for each. Read it for a fuller comparison of the two faiths, especially if questions about Jesus’ identity or the Christian account of His death came up in your conversation.

 

 

Yellow paperback cover of No God but One: Allah or Jesus? by Nabeel Qureshi, with a cross and crescent.

 

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Product Title

16 px collapsible text is perfect for longer content like paragraphs and descriptions. It’s a great way to give people more information while keeping your layout clean. Link your text to anything, including an external website or a different page. You can set your text box to expand and collapse when people click, so they can read more or less info.

$320

Product Title

16 px collapsible text is perfect for longer content like paragraphs and descriptions. It’s a great way to give people more information while keeping your layout clean. Link your text to anything, including an external website or a different page. You can set your text box to expand and collapse when people click, so they can read more or less info.

$900

Product Title

16 px collapsible text is perfect for longer content like paragraphs and descriptions. It’s a great way to give people more information while keeping your layout clean. Link your text to anything, including an external website or a different page. You can set your text box to expand and collapse when people click, so they can read more or less info.

$560

Product Title

16 px collapsible text is perfect for longer content like paragraphs and descriptions. It’s a great way to give people more information while keeping your layout clean. Link your text to anything, including an external website or a different page. You can set your text box to expand and collapse when people click, so they can read more or less info.

$280

Recommended Products For This Post
 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page